anti-elab-337 DCCC587/2020 Possession of corrosive substance

文件編號:

anti-elab-337

案件編號:

DCCC587/2020

控罪:

Possession of corrosive substance

涉事日期 :

2020-03-23

涉事地點 :

Sheung Shui

判決理由書/裁決書撮要(由AI生成)

以下撮要以AI生成及/或翻譯,內容以原來的判決理由書/裁決書為準

No Reasons for Verdict.

判刑理由書撮要(由AI生成)

以下撮要以AI生成及/或翻譯,內容以原來的判刑理由書為準

The written judgment states that in the early hours of 23 March 2020, the defendant rode a bicycle to the married police officers’ quarters in Sheung Shui, wearing a duckbill cap and a mask. He bound the west gate with wire, set fire outside the door and threw three lit petrol bombs into the premises, causing fire damage to a parked private car. Upon arrest, police found a lighter, a liquid containing toluene and a broad-bladed hoe, and he admitted to three offences: arson, possession of a corrosive substance and possession of a tool for unlawful purposes.

The general sentencing guideline for intentional arson is 4 to 6 years’ imprisonment, for possession of a corrosive substance up to 3 years, and for possession of a tool for unlawful purposes up to 2 years; in this case, baseline sentences of 5½ years, 15 months and 9 months were adopted respectively, each reduced by one third for the guilty plea.

The defendant’s actions were premeditated; he wore a mask to conceal his identity and used wire to lock the gate, delaying rescue, and by throwing petrol bombs he created a high potential risk to life and property; he also damaged others’ property and openly posed a serious challenge to the rule of law. Mitigating factors include that the defendant is 62 years old, has no significant prior convictions, pleaded guilty early and has a good family background.

Arson is an extremely serious offence in Hong Kong’s high-rise, densely populated areas and must be met with severe punishment to achieve deterrence and protect the lives and property of the public; even if it does not result in casualties, its potential danger cannot be overlooked.

The defendant was sentenced to 42 months’ imprisonment for intentional arson; for possession of a corrosive substance and possession of a tool suitable for unlawful purposes he was sentenced to 10 months and 6 months respectively, to run concurrently; he is also required to pay HKD 5,000 in compensation within 14 days. (Translated from Chinese to English by AI)

查看完整判刑理由書

Case Details

File No. anti-elab-337
Case No. DCCC587/2020
Judge LEE Hing Nin, Clement
Court District Court
Plea Plead guilty
Verdict Convicted
Charge Possession of corrosive substance
Sentence Imprisonment
Incident Date 2020-03-23
Incident Location Sheung Shui
Reasons for Verdict (AI Summary) No Reasons for Verdict.
Reasons for Sentence View
Reasons for Sentence (AI Summary) The written judgment states that in the early hours of 23 March 2020, the defendant rode a bicycle to the married police officers’ quarters in Sheung Shui, wearing a duckbill cap and a mask. He bound the west gate with wire, set fire outside the door and threw three lit petrol bombs into the premises, causing fire damage to a parked private car. Upon arrest, police found a lighter, a liquid containing toluene and a broad-bladed hoe, and he admitted to three offences: arson, possession of a corrosive substance and possession of a tool for unlawful purposes.</p><p>The general sentencing guideline for intentional arson is 4 to 6 years’ imprisonment, for possession of a corrosive substance up to 3 years, and for possession of a tool for unlawful purposes up to 2 years; in this case, baseline sentences of 5½ years, 15 months and 9 months were adopted respectively, each reduced by one third for the guilty plea.</p><p>The defendant’s actions were premeditated; he wore a mask to conceal his identity and used wire to lock the gate, delaying rescue, and by throwing petrol bombs he created a high potential risk to life and property; he also damaged others’ property and openly posed a serious challenge to the rule of law. Mitigating factors include that the defendant is 62 years old, has no significant prior convictions, pleaded guilty early and has a good family background.</p><p>Arson is an extremely serious offence in Hong Kong's high-rise, densely populated areas and must be met with severe punishment to achieve deterrence and protect the lives and property of the public; even if it does not result in casualties, its potential danger cannot be overlooked.</p><p>The defendant was sentenced to 42 months’ imprisonment for intentional arson; for possession of a corrosive substance and possession of a tool suitable for unlawful purposes he was sentenced to 10 months and 6 months respectively, to run concurrently; he is also required to pay HKD 5,000 in compensation within 14 days. (Translated from Chinese to English by AI)

裁判官/法官:

LEE Hing Nin, Clement

法院:

District Court

認罪:

Plead guilty

罪成:

Convicted

判刑:

Imprisonment

相近案件